ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE

To determine the anticaries potential of toothpastes distributed by the primary health care public clinics (UBS) of Manaus, AM.

METHODS

Ninety-nine tubes of toothpaste from four commercial brands were collected from October 7, 2019 to October 11, 2019 in 16 UBS. They were assigned a code by brand and source UBS. According to the information on the packaging, the four brands and their batches were formulated with sodium monofluorophosphate (Na₂FPO₃) and most (91%) had calcium carbonate (CaCO₃) as an abrasive. We determined the concentrations of total fluoride (TF = TSF + InsF) and total soluble fluoride (TSF = F ions^- or FPO₃^2-), to certify whether they were in compliance with resolution ANVISA RDC No. 530 (maximum of 1,500 ppm TF) and whether they had anticaries potential (minimum of 1,000 ppm TSF). The analyses were performed with a ion- specific electrode.

RESULTS

The concentrations (ppm F) of TF [mean; standard deviation (SD); n] found in toothpaste brands A (1,502.3; SD = 45.6; n = 33), B (1,135.5; SD = 52.7; n = 48) and D (936.8; SD = 20.5; N = 8) were close to those stated on the package, 1,500, 1,100 and 1,000 ppm F, respectively. In toothpaste C, we found a mean of 274.1 ppm (SD = 219.7; n = 10) of TF, which diverges from the declared concentration of 1,500 ppm F. In addition, the five tubes of lot no. 11681118 of toothpaste C did not contain fluoride. Regarding TSF, with the exception of toothpaste D (937.9; SD = 40.29), the others had a lower concentration than their respective TF.

CONCLUSION

We found serious problems of quantity and quality of fluoride in toothpaste distributed by the SUS in Manaus, which shows the need for surveillance of these products and confirms the urgency of revising resolution RDC No. 530.

Toothpastes, supply & distribution; Dentifrices, chemistry; Fluorides, standards; Dental Caries, prevention & control; Dental Health Services

INTRODUCTION

Fluoride toothpaste is recommended for preventing tooth decay because it is associated with its decline, which has been observed both in developed¹1. Bratthall D, Hänsel-Petersson G, Sundberg H. Reasons for the caries decline: what do the experts believe? Eur J Oral Sci. 1996;104(4 Pt 2):416-22. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0722.1996.tb00104.x
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0722.1996... and developing countries, such as Brazil²2. Cury JA, Tenuta LMA, Ribeiro CCC, Paes Leme AF. The importance of fluoride dentifrices to the current dental caries prevalence in Brazil. Braz Dent J. 2004;15(3):167-74. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-64402004000300001
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-6440200400... . Toothpaste is also considered the most rational means of using fluoride because, simultaneously with the disorganization of the dental biofilm by brushing, fluoride is released into the oral cavity to interfere with the development of caries lesions or to repair existing lesions³3. Cury JA, Tenuta LMA. Evidence-based recommendation on toothpaste use. Braz Oral Res. 2014;28 Spec Nº:1-7. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.50000001
https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.5... ,⁴4. Tenuta LMA, Cury JA. Laboratory and human studies to estimate anticaries efficacy of fluoride toothpastes. Monogr Oral Sci. 2013;23:108-24. https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479
https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479... . However, it is essential that fluoride be chemically soluble in the formulation⁵5. Stookey GK. Are all fluoride dentifrices the same? In: Wei SH, editor. Clinical uses of fluorides. Philadelphia, PA: Lea & Febiger; 1985. p. 105-31.in order to be bioavailable in the mouth during brushing⁶6. Coelho CSS, Cury JA, Tabchoury CPM. Chemically soluble fluoride in Na2FPO3/CaCO3-based toothpaste as an indicator of fluoride bioavailability in saliva during and after toothbrushing. Caries Res. 2020;54(2):185-93. https://doi.org/10.1159/000506439
https://doi.org/10.1159/000506439... . The effect of fluoride present in toothpaste on reduction of caries is based on evidence⁷7. Marinho VC, Higgins JP, Sheiham A, Logan S. Fluoride toothpastes for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2003;(1):CD002278. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD002278
https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD00227... and the minimum concentration of 1,000 ppm F is still recommended¹⁰10. Splieth CH, Banerjee A, Bottenberg P, Breschi L, Campus G, Ekstrand KR, et al. How to intervene in the caries process in children: A Joint ORCA and EFCD Expert Delphi Consensus Statement. Caries Res. 2020;54(4):297-305. https://doi.org/10.1159/000507692
https://doi.org/10.1159/000507692... . Therefore, there is a need not only for toothpaste to contain fluoride, but also to have a minimum concentration of soluble fluoride so that the population can benefit from caries control¹¹11. Cury JA, Miranda LFB, Caldarelli PG, Tabchoury CPM. Dentifrícios fluoretados e o SUS-Brasil: o que precisa ser mudado? Tempus Actas Saude Coletiva. 2020;14(1):9-27. https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.2631
https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.26... .

In Brazil, 90% of the population uses toothpaste formulated with the combination of calcium carbonate (CaCO₃) as an abrasive and sodium monofluorophosphate (Na₂FPO₃) as a fluoride source salt²2. Cury JA, Tenuta LMA, Ribeiro CCC, Paes Leme AF. The importance of fluoride dentifrices to the current dental caries prevalence in Brazil. Braz Dent J. 2004;15(3):167-74. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-64402004000300001
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-6440200400... ,¹²12. Ricomini Filho AP, Tenuta LMA, Fernandes FSF, Calvo AFB, Kusano SC, Cury JA. Fluoride concentration in the top-selling Brazilian toothpastes purchased at different regions. Braz Dent J. 2012;23(1):45-8. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-64402012000100008
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-6440201200... . This type of formulation (CaCO₃/Na₂FPO₃) is relatively stable since the fluoride is bound to the phosphate, therefore it does not immediately react with the Ca⁺⁺ in the abrasive. However, due to the storage time, the MFP (FPO₃^2-) undergoes hydrolysis and the released fluoride ion is insolubilized by the Ca⁺⁺ in the abrasive⁴4. Tenuta LMA, Cury JA. Laboratory and human studies to estimate anticaries efficacy of fluoride toothpastes. Monogr Oral Sci. 2013;23:108-24. https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479
https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479... ,¹³13. Cury JA, Dantas EDV, Tenuta LMA, Romão DA, Tabchoury CPM, Nóbrega DF, et al. Concentração de fluoreto nos dentifrícios a base de MFP/CaCO3 mais vendidos no Brasil, ao final dos seus prazos de validade. Rev Assoc Paul Cir Dent. 2015;69(3):248-51.. On the other hand, hydrated silica (SiO₂) is chemically compatible with all fluoride salts (NaF, SnF₂, AmF, Na₂FPO₃) used in toothpaste. However, formulations with CaCO₃/Na₂FPO₃ have social impact especially for developing countries¹⁴14. Goldman AS, Yee R, Holmgren CJ, Benzian H. Global affordability of fluoride toothpaste. Global Health. 2008;4:7. https://doi.org/10.1186/1744-8603-4-7
https://doi.org/10.1186/1744-8603-4-7... like Brazil. First, because they cost 2 to 3 times less than formulations with SiO₂; second, and most importantly, they are widely distributed to underprivileged populations, as is done in Brazil by the Unified Health System (SUS). Thus, bids from small Brazilian manufacturers of toothpaste with CaCO₃/Na₂FPO₃ win the tenders for purchases made by city halls¹¹11. Cury JA, Miranda LFB, Caldarelli PG, Tabchoury CPM. Dentifrícios fluoretados e o SUS-Brasil: o que precisa ser mudado? Tempus Actas Saude Coletiva. 2020;14(1):9-27. https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.2631
https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.26... .

The quality of the fluoride in toothpaste brands available in the Brazilian market is regulated by the updated resolution RDC No. 530, of August 4, 2021¹⁵15. Ministério da Saúde (BR), Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária. RDC Nº 530, de 4 de agosto de 2021. Publicado em: 11/08/2021 | Edição: 151 | Seção: 1 | Página: 119. of ANVISA, but like the regulations of the Southern Common Market (Mercosur)¹⁶16. MERCOSUL. MERCOSUL/GMC/RES Nº 48/02. Regulamento técnico MERCOSUL sobre lista de substâncias que os produtos de higiene pessoal, cosméticos e perfumes não devem conter, exceto nas condições e com as restrições estabelecidas. Brasília (DF): Sistema de Informação do Comércio Exterior; 2002 [cited 2020 Sep 4]. Available from: http://www.sice.oas.org/trade/mrcsrs/resolutions/res4802p.as
http://www.sice.oas.org/trade/mrcsrs/res... and the European Union (EU)¹⁷17. European Union. Statutory Instruments. Consumer Protection: The Cosmetic Products (Safety) Regulations 2008: Nº 1284. London (UK: Stationery Office; 2008 [cited 2020 Sep 4]. Available from: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2008/1284/pdfs/uksi_20081284_en.pdf
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2008/... , the resolution only establishes the maximum concentration of total fluoride (TF), which is 0.15% (1,500 ppm F; mg F/kg), but not how much of this fluoride must be soluble in the formulation for anticaries efficacy¹⁸18. Cury JA, Caldarelli PG, Tenuta LMA. Necessity to review the Brazilian regulation about fluoride toothpastes. Rev Saude Publica. 2015;49:74. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-8910.2015049005768
https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-8910.20150... . As a result, in toothpaste brands sold in the Brazilian market¹²12. Ricomini Filho AP, Tenuta LMA, Fernandes FSF, Calvo AFB, Kusano SC, Cury JA. Fluoride concentration in the top-selling Brazilian toothpastes purchased at different regions. Braz Dent J. 2012;23(1):45-8. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-64402012000100008
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-6440201200... and distributed by the SUS¹¹11. Cury JA, Miranda LFB, Caldarelli PG, Tabchoury CPM. Dentifrícios fluoretados e o SUS-Brasil: o que precisa ser mudado? Tempus Actas Saude Coletiva. 2020;14(1):9-27. https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.2631
https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.26... , we found that the concentration of chemically soluble fluoride is much lower than the minimum required for anticaries potential.

The Health Department of Manaus, the capital city of Amazonas State, has the task of promoting universal access to health services according to the principles established by the SUS, which includes supplying toothpaste to underprivileged populations. Since the quality of the fluoride in toothpaste consumed by the population of Manaus is not known, the aim of this study was to evaluate whether these toothpaste brands were in compliance with resolution RDC No. 530¹⁵15. Ministério da Saúde (BR), Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária. RDC Nº 530, de 4 de agosto de 2021. Publicado em: 11/08/2021 | Edição: 151 | Seção: 1 | Página: 119. of ANVISA in terms of TF, and whether they also had enough concentration of soluble fluoride to have anticaries potential¹⁹19. Chávez BA, Vergel GB, Cáceres CP, Perazzo MF, Vieira-Andrade RG, Cury JA. Fluoride content in children’s dentifrices marketed in Lima, Peru. Braz Oral Res. 2019;33:e051. https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-2019.vol33.0051
https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-201... .

METHODS

Sampling

The toothpaste samples were obtained in primary health care public clinics (UBS) in the city of Manaus AM, Brazil, with the agreement of the Health Department (agreement no. 48/2019). We chose 16 UBS (Table 3) which had dental surgeons who are internship preceptors of the School of Dentistry at Universidade Federal do Amazonas. Ninety-nine tubes of fluoride toothpaste were collected, one tube of each batch of toothpaste available at the UBS. The toothpastes were assigned a code by brand and source UBS. The information on the packaging of the toothpaste collected is described in Table 1. The toothpaste tubes were collected between October 7, 2019 and October 11, 2019, and chemical analysis was performed between October 18, 2019 and November 7, 2019 in the laboratory of Oral Biochemistry at FOP-Unicamp, as an activity of the PROCAD/Amazon agreement 88881.200487/2018-1.

Determining Fluoride Concentration

Fluoride concentration was measured with a ion-specific electrode through the direct technique, using a validated methodology²⁰20. Cury JA, Oliveira MJL, Martins CC, Tenuta LMA, Paiva SM. Available fluoride in toothpastes used by Brazilian children. Braz Dent J. 2010;21(5):396-400. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-64402010000500003
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-6440201000... ,²¹21. Martinez-Mier EA, Tenuta LMA, Carey CM, Cury JA, Loveren C, Ekstrand KR, et al.; ORCA Fluoride in Toothpaste Analysis Work Group. European Organization for Caries Research Workshop: methodology for determination of potentially available fluoride in toothpastes. Caries Res. 2019;53(2):119-36. https://doi.org/10.1159/000490196
https://doi.org/10.1159/000490196... . The concentrations (ppm F = mg F/Kg) of total fluoride (TF = TSF + InsF), total soluble fluoride (TSF = fluoride as FPO₃^2- + IF) and ionic fluoride (IF) were determined and the concentration of fluoride as an FPO₃^2- ion (= TSF - IF) and as insoluble fluoride (InsF = TF found - TSF found) were estimated. Summarily, between 90 and 110 mg of toothpaste from each tube were weighed and homogenized in 10 mL of purified water. Duplicates of 0.25 mL of the toothpaste suspension were transferred to tubes marked TF. The remainder of the toothpaste suspension was centrifuged and 0.25 mL duplicates of the supernatant were transferred to tubes marked TSF and IF. We added 0.25 mL of 2 M HCl to the TF and TSF tubes, and after one hour at 45°C, the samples were neutralized with 0.50 mL of 1 M NaOH and buffered with 1.0 mL of TISAB II (1 M acetate buffer, pH 5.0, containing 1 M NaCl and 0.4% CDTA). We added sequentially to the IF tubes 0.50 mL of 1 M NaOH, 1.0 mL of TISAB II and 0.25 mL of 2 M HCl.

The analyses were performed with a fluoride ion-specific electrode (Thermo Scientific Orion 96-09, Orion Research, Cambridge, MA, USA) coupled to an ion analyzer (Thermo Scientific Orion Star A214, Orion Research). The electrode was calibrated in triplicate, with standard fluoride solutions of 0.0625 to 4 µg F/mL prepared in 0.25 M HCl, 0.25 M NaOH and TISAB II 50% (v/v). The logarithm data of the fluoride concentrations of the standards and the respective mV values were analyzed by linear regression, using Microsoft Excel software (Microsoft^®, Redmond, USA). The mean linear regression coefficient obtained was R²2. Cury JA, Tenuta LMA, Ribeiro CCC, Paes Leme AF. The importance of fluoride dentifrices to the current dental caries prevalence in Brazil. Braz Dent J. 2004;15(3):167-74. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-64402004000300001
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-6440200400... = 0.9998 (n = 14) and the mathematical regression equation was used to estimate the fluoride concentration in each analytical mixture (µg F/mL). The average percentage of the coefficient of variation of duplicates was less than 2.5%. The fluoride concentration in each brand of toothpaste was estimated based on the weight of the toothpaste in the analysis tube and expressed in ppm of F (mg F/Kg).

Data Analysis

The means of the dosage duplicates were calculated and used to estimate the mean and standard deviation of the TF, TSF and InsF concentrations for each brand of toothpaste, using the Microsoft Excel software (Microsoft^®). We estimated the anticaries potential of the concentration of TSF in the distributed toothpastes¹⁹19. Chávez BA, Vergel GB, Cáceres CP, Perazzo MF, Vieira-Andrade RG, Cury JA. Fluoride content in children’s dentifrices marketed in Lima, Peru. Braz Oral Res. 2019;33:e051. https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-2019.vol33.0051
https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-201... .

RESULTS

Table 1 shows that of the 99 toothpastes collected, 33 tubes (12 lots) were of Brand A, 48 (19 lots) of brand B, 10 (two lots) of brand C and 8 (two lots) of brand D. All were formulated with sodium monofluorophosphate (Na₂FPO₃) at concentrations between 1,000 and 1,500 ppm F. With the exception of toothpaste D, which was formulated with SiO₂, the toothpastes contained CaCO₃ as an abrasive. With the exception of sample lot 099 of brand B, all toothpastes collected were within the specified expiration date. Toothpaste samples C (n = 10) and D (N = 8) were not available at all 16 UBS. The fact that there were only two batches of toothpastes C and D reflected in the results for fluoride concentration of the products distributed by the UBS and districts.

The figure shows the fluoride concentrations found in all tubes of each brand of toothpaste distributed at the UBS. With the exception of toothpaste C, the mean concentration (ppm F) (±SD; n) of TF found in brands D (936.8 ± 20.5; 8), A (1,502.3 ± 45.6; 33) and B (1,135.5 ± 52.7; 48) was very close to the manufacturers’ specifications. Regarding the analysis of toothpaste C, besides the concentration of TF being much lower than the 1,500 ppm F specified (274.1 ± 219.7; 10), the SD was extremely high (80% of the mean), reflecting the difference in concentration of the two batches of this product.

As for the values (mean ± SD; n) of TSF found (figure and Table 2), only toothpaste D exhibited a concentration (937.9 ± 40.3; 8) close to the TF found; insoluble fluoride (InsF) was not found in this product (Figure). In the other brands, much of the TF found (figure) was not soluble as TSF (FPO₃^2- + F^-), with 36, 57 and 70% of InsF in toothpastes C, A and B, respectively. The case of toothpaste C is totally anomalous.

As for the anticaries potential¹⁹19. Chávez BA, Vergel GB, Cáceres CP, Perazzo MF, Vieira-Andrade RG, Cury JA. Fluoride content in children’s dentifrices marketed in Lima, Peru. Braz Oral Res. 2019;33:e051. https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-2019.vol33.0051
https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-201... of the toothpaste brands distributed in Manaus, Table 2 took into account the average TSF concentration of all toothpaste lots of each brand, Table 3 the average concentration of brands that were being distributed at each UBS, and Table 4 the location of the UBS according to the health district of Manaus. According to Table 2, the toothpaste brands analyzed can be grouped into the following descending order of anticaries potential (Good to Null): D > A > B = C (lot 11684118) > C (lot 11681118).

Table 3 shows that no UBS were distributing toothpaste with exclusively good or null anticaries potential, the best result ranging from very low to good in six of the 16 UBS, which was reflected in the assisted populations living in the four health districts of Manaus (Table 4). Thus, only the Western District distributed toothpaste with very low to good anticaries potential, while the other districts had toothpastes with null to good potential.

DISCUSSION

The WHO has recommended affordable fluoride toothpaste for populations as one of the strategies for reducing tooth decay¹⁴14. Goldman AS, Yee R, Holmgren CJ, Benzian H. Global affordability of fluoride toothpaste. Global Health. 2008;4:7. https://doi.org/10.1186/1744-8603-4-7
https://doi.org/10.1186/1744-8603-4-7... since this disease affects more than 2.5 billion people around the world²²22. Kassebaum NJ, Smith AGC, Bernabé E, Fleming TD, Reynolds AE, Vos T, et al.; GBD 2015 Oral Health Collaborators. Global, Regional, and National Prevalence, Incidence, and Disability-Adjusted Life Years for Oral Conditions for 195 Countries, 1990-2015: a systematic analysis for the global burden of diseases, injuries, and risk factors. J Dent Res. 2017;96(4):380-7. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022034517693566
https://doi.org/10.1177/0022034517693566... . Toothpaste brands with CaCO₃ as the abrasive has lower cost (2-3x<) than those formulated with SiO₂³3. Cury JA, Tenuta LMA. Evidence-based recommendation on toothpaste use. Braz Oral Res. 2014;28 Spec Nº:1-7. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.50000001
https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.5... ,¹⁴14. Goldman AS, Yee R, Holmgren CJ, Benzian H. Global affordability of fluoride toothpaste. Global Health. 2008;4:7. https://doi.org/10.1186/1744-8603-4-7
https://doi.org/10.1186/1744-8603-4-7... , and there are fluoride toothpastes in the Brazilian market formulated with CaCO₃/Na₂FPO₃ of acceptable quality in terms of the concentration of potentially active fluoride against caries¹²12. Ricomini Filho AP, Tenuta LMA, Fernandes FSF, Calvo AFB, Kusano SC, Cury JA. Fluoride concentration in the top-selling Brazilian toothpastes purchased at different regions. Braz Dent J. 2012;23(1):45-8. https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-64402012000100008
https://doi.org/10.1590/s0103-6440201200... ,¹³13. Cury JA, Dantas EDV, Tenuta LMA, Romão DA, Tabchoury CPM, Nóbrega DF, et al. Concentração de fluoreto nos dentifrícios a base de MFP/CaCO3 mais vendidos no Brasil, ao final dos seus prazos de validade. Rev Assoc Paul Cir Dent. 2015;69(3):248-51.,²³23. Marin LM, Vieira W, Tenuta LMA, Tabchoury COM, Cury JA. Fluoride concentration in local dentifrices from Brazilian regions. Rev Assoc Paul Cir Dent. 2017;71(1):60-5.. Although toothpaste based on CaCO₃/Na₂FPO₃ is affordable in Brazil (R$ 0.028/g), 50% of the population would have to work approximately one hour a day just to buy a 90 g tube of toothpaste. Therefore, due to social inequality in Brazil, the Brazilian government runs a preventive action program for SUS users as an action to promote oral health²⁴24. Antunes JLF, Narvai PC. Políticas de saúde bucal no Brasil e seu impacto sobre as desigualdades em saúde. Rev Saude Publica. 2010;44(2):360-5. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-89102010005000002
https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-8910201000... . Toothpaste is bought through a public bidding process and the winning firms are usually from local manufacturers of toothpaste based on CaCO₃/Na₂FPO₃¹¹11. Cury JA, Miranda LFB, Caldarelli PG, Tabchoury CPM. Dentifrícios fluoretados e o SUS-Brasil: o que precisa ser mudado? Tempus Actas Saude Coletiva. 2020;14(1):9-27. https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.2631
https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.26... . The quality of this toothpaste in terms of anticaries potential could be guaranteed not only in Brazil, but worldwide, if there were support for government regulations on the sale of toothpaste¹⁸18. Cury JA, Caldarelli PG, Tenuta LMA. Necessity to review the Brazilian regulation about fluoride toothpastes. Rev Saude Publica. 2015;49:74. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-8910.2015049005768
https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-8910.20150... .

Our results showed that the total fluoride concentration (TF) found in the toothpaste distributed by the SUS in Manaus (Figure) matches the specifications on the packaging of three of the four brands analyzed (Table 1). The exception was toothpaste C, in which we expected to find 1,500 ppm TF (Table 1), but the value found was 82% lower. In addition to the low mean value found, of 274.1 ppm TF in this product, another relevant aspect was the high standard deviation from the mean (80%) of the 10 tubes analyzed. This is easily explained by the difference in TF concentration found between the two batches of this brand. While in the 5 tubes of toothpaste C of batch 11684118, we found a mean of 479.6 ppm F TF, in batch 11681118 we only found 68.4 ppm F TF. Thus, the toothpaste of batch 11684118 had an amount of Na₂FPO₃ three times lower than stated on the packaging, while lot 11684118 did not contain any fluoride at all. The mean value of 68.4 ppm F TF in the tubes of this batch can be attributed to the residual fluoride of the ingredients used in its formulation. Thus, this toothpaste violates Brazilian¹⁵15. Ministério da Saúde (BR), Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária. RDC Nº 530, de 4 de agosto de 2021. Publicado em: 11/08/2021 | Edição: 151 | Seção: 1 | Página: 119. and Mercosur regulations¹⁶16. MERCOSUL. MERCOSUL/GMC/RES Nº 48/02. Regulamento técnico MERCOSUL sobre lista de substâncias que os produtos de higiene pessoal, cosméticos e perfumes não devem conter, exceto nas condições e com as restrições estabelecidas. Brasília (DF): Sistema de Informação do Comércio Exterior; 2002 [cited 2020 Sep 4]. Available from: http://www.sice.oas.org/trade/mrcsrs/resolutions/res4802p.as
http://www.sice.oas.org/trade/mrcsrs/res... since it was not formulated as stated on the labeling. It is also admissible that the supplier of the product for the SUS in Manaus failed to comply with the tender because the standardized specification for such products is that toothpaste must contain fluoride in the concentration of 1,000 to 1,500 ppm F. This blatant aberration of not finding the stated TF concentration in toothpaste is rare in our 40 years evaluating toothpaste worldwide, and it has only been observed in two brands of toothpaste from China, one being sold in Chile²⁵25. Giacaman RA, Carrera CA, Muñoz-Sandoval C, Fernandez C, Cury JA. Fluoride content in toothpastes commercialized for children in Chile and discussion on professional recommendations of use. Int J Paediatr Dent. 2013;23(2):77-83. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-263X.2012.01226.x
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-263X.2012... and the other in Peru¹⁹19. Chávez BA, Vergel GB, Cáceres CP, Perazzo MF, Vieira-Andrade RG, Cury JA. Fluoride content in children’s dentifrices marketed in Lima, Peru. Braz Oral Res. 2019;33:e051. https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-2019.vol33.0051
https://doi.org/10.1590/1807-3107bor-201... . On the other hand, the most important aspect in terms of health is how much of the TF in toothpaste is chemically soluble to have anticaries potential³3. Cury JA, Tenuta LMA. Evidence-based recommendation on toothpaste use. Braz Oral Res. 2014;28 Spec Nº:1-7. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.50000001
https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.5...

4. Tenuta LMA, Cury JA. Laboratory and human studies to estimate anticaries efficacy of fluoride toothpastes. Monogr Oral Sci. 2013;23:108-24. https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479
https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479... -⁵5. Stookey GK. Are all fluoride dentifrices the same? In: Wei SH, editor. Clinical uses of fluorides. Philadelphia, PA: Lea & Febiger; 1985. p. 105-31..

Thus, of the four brands of toothpaste analyzed that were being distributed by the SUS in Manaus, only brand D would have a good anticaries potential (Table 2) because it exhibited an average of 937.9 ppm F of total soluble fluoride (TSF), very close to the minimum value of 1,000 ppm F necessary for anticaries efficacy⁴4. Tenuta LMA, Cury JA. Laboratory and human studies to estimate anticaries efficacy of fluoride toothpastes. Monogr Oral Sci. 2013;23:108-24. https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479
https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479... . In addition, all fluoride in this toothpaste is soluble (figure) since it was formulated with SiO₂, an abrasive compatible with all fluoride salts, including Na₂FPO₃, used in this formulation (Table 1). On the other hand, the concentration of TSF found in the other brands of toothpaste was very low. The low concentration of TSF found in brands A, B and C (Table 2) is explained not only because they contain CaCO₃ as an abrasive (Table 1), since it inactivates fluoride³3. Cury JA, Tenuta LMA. Evidence-based recommendation on toothpaste use. Braz Oral Res. 2014;28 Spec Nº:1-7. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.50000001
https://doi.org/10.1590/S1806-83242014.5... ,⁴4. Tenuta LMA, Cury JA. Laboratory and human studies to estimate anticaries efficacy of fluoride toothpastes. Monogr Oral Sci. 2013;23:108-24. https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479
https://doi.org/10.1159/000350479... , but also by the fact that, with the exception of brand A, these toothpaste brands were formulated with less than 1,500 ppm TF.

As 57% of the TF in brand A was insoluble (Figure), 642.3 ppm remained as TSF, which gives it low anticaries potential (Table 2). Brand B, on the other hand, in addition to being formulated with 1,100 ppm F TF (Table 1), has 70% insoluble fluoride, meaning only 339.9 ppm of TSF, which gives it very low anticaries potential. Compared to product A, the higher percentage of InsF in B can be explained by the fact that their expiration date is close (Table 1), including batch 99 toothpaste of Brand B, distributed at UBS Balbina Mestrinho, which had expired (April 2019) six months before collection. In the toothpaste of this batch, of the 1,100 ppm of TF added, only 108.9 ppm were soluble (Table 2), that is, 90% of its TF of was insoluble, therefore not exhibiting any anticaries effect. This result of decreased concentration of TSF in toothpaste brands formulated with CaCO₃/Na₂FPO₃ according to the time elapsed since manufacture is well known in the literature¹³13. Cury JA, Dantas EDV, Tenuta LMA, Romão DA, Tabchoury CPM, Nóbrega DF, et al. Concentração de fluoreto nos dentifrícios a base de MFP/CaCO3 mais vendidos no Brasil, ao final dos seus prazos de validade. Rev Assoc Paul Cir Dent. 2015;69(3):248-51., but the percentage values found in this study were much higher.

On the other hand, the case of toothpaste C is totally atypical because the very low average concentration of 42.3 ppm of TSF found in the tubes of lot 11681118 is due to the fact that it has not even been fluoridated, which gives it zero anticaries potential. In toothpastes C of batch 11684118, a mean of 324.1 ppm of TSF was found, since 32% of the 479.7 ppm of the TF found was insoluble, which gives it a very low anticaries potential (Table 2).

Considering that of the 99 toothpaste tubes analyzed, only the eight of brand D can be considered to have good anticaries potential (Table 2), which represents only 8% of the sample, it is very unlikely that any UBS of Manaus was distributing only good quality toothpaste to its users, as the data in Table 3 show. Thus, if at one end there were people receiving toothpaste with good anticaries potential, in the case of brand D, at the other there were people receiving toothpaste with no protection against caries (Null), as was the case of batch 11681118 of toothpaste C. Similarly, no health district of the city of Manaus had benefited from the quality of fluoride toothpaste distributed, as shown in Table 4.

This problem of low-quality fluoride toothpaste is not exclusive to Brazil and has been reported in other countries²⁶26. Benzian H, Holmgren C, Buijs M, Loveren C, Weijden F, Palenstein Helderman W. Total and free available fluoride in toothpastes in Brunei, Cambodia, Laos, the Netherlands and Suriname. Int Dent J. 2012;62(4):213-21. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1875-595X.2012.00116.x
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1875-595X.2012... ,²⁷27. Fernández CE, Carrera CA, Muñoz-Sandoval C, Cury JA, Giacaman RA. Stability of chemically available fluoride in Chilean toothpastes. Int J Paediatr Dent. 2017;27(6):496-505. https://doi.org/10.1111/ipd.12288
https://doi.org/10.1111/ipd.12288... . With the exception of the regulations of the US²⁸28. US Food and Drug Administration. CFR – Code of Federal Regulations. Title 21: Food and drugs. Washington (DC): FDA; 2013 [cited 2019 Feb 20]. Chapter I, Food and Drug Administration Department of Health and Human Services, Subchapter D, Drugs from human use (part 355): anticaries drugs products for over the counter human use. Disponível em: Available from: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2013-title21-vol5/pdf/CFR-2013-title21-vol5-chapI.pdf
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-... and Madagascar²⁹29. Bureau des Normes de Madagascar. Norme Malagasy. NMG/ISO 11609:2017. Medecine bucco-dentaire – dentifrices: exigences, methodes d’essai et marquage. Madagascar: BNM; 2018 [cited 2020 Oct 30]. Available from: http://blog.aoi-fr.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/Normes-Dentifrice-Madagascra-aout-2018.pdf
http://blog.aoi-fr.org/wp-content/upload... , most of the world’s regulations¹⁶16. MERCOSUL. MERCOSUL/GMC/RES Nº 48/02. Regulamento técnico MERCOSUL sobre lista de substâncias que os produtos de higiene pessoal, cosméticos e perfumes não devem conter, exceto nas condições e com as restrições estabelecidas. Brasília (DF): Sistema de Informação do Comércio Exterior; 2002 [cited 2020 Sep 4]. Available from: http://www.sice.oas.org/trade/mrcsrs/resolutions/res4802p.as
http://www.sice.oas.org/trade/mrcsrs/res... ,¹⁷17. European Union. Statutory Instruments. Consumer Protection: The Cosmetic Products (Safety) Regulations 2008: Nº 1284. London (UK: Stationery Office; 2008 [cited 2020 Sep 4]. Available from: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2008/1284/pdfs/uksi_20081284_en.pdf
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2008/... do not set forth that toothpaste have soluble fluoride for anticaries efficacy, but the FDI has recently signaled that this needs to change³⁰30. FDI World Dental Federation. Promoting dental health through fluoride toothpaste. Geneva (CH): FDI; 2018 [cited 2019 Sep 4]. Available from: https://www.fdiworlddental.org/resources/policy-statements/promoting-dental-health-through-fluoride-toothpaste
https://www.fdiworlddental.org/resources... .

Our results corroborate previous publications¹¹11. Cury JA, Miranda LFB, Caldarelli PG, Tabchoury CPM. Dentifrícios fluoretados e o SUS-Brasil: o que precisa ser mudado? Tempus Actas Saude Coletiva. 2020;14(1):9-27. https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.2631
https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.26... ,¹⁸18. Cury JA, Caldarelli PG, Tenuta LMA. Necessity to review the Brazilian regulation about fluoride toothpastes. Rev Saude Publica. 2015;49:74. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-8910.2015049005768
https://doi.org/10.1590/S0034-8910.20150... and clearly show the need for a revision of the Brazilian regulation ANVISA RDC No. 530¹⁵15. Ministério da Saúde (BR), Agência Nacional de Vigilância Sanitária. RDC Nº 530, de 4 de agosto de 2021. Publicado em: 11/08/2021 | Edição: 151 | Seção: 1 | Página: 119. to ensure that the population, especially the one assisted by the SUS, receives fluoride toothpaste with a minimum concentration of soluble fluoride with anticaries potential. As Brazil is part of the Mercosur, there may be multilateral interests that need to be agreed between the countries of this common market for changes in legislation. While this does not happen, the alternative would be for SUS managers to draft tender notices with the following terms¹¹11. Cury JA, Miranda LFB, Caldarelli PG, Tabchoury CPM. Dentifrícios fluoretados e o SUS-Brasil: o que precisa ser mudado? Tempus Actas Saude Coletiva. 2020;14(1):9-27. https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.2631
https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.26... :

1. Toothpaste must contain no more than 1,500 ppm (mg/kg) of total fluoride (TF);

2. At least 1,000 ppm of TF must be chemically soluble (TSF) in a fresh (newly manufactured) sample;

3. Toothpaste must keep at least 800 ppm of chemically soluble fluoride (TSF) for 2 years after manufacture.

The reason for the maximum amount of 1,500 ppm of TF is product safety for free sale, the requirement of 1,000 ppm of soluble fluoride aims to ensure a minimum anticaries effect, and 800 soluble ppm for 2 years aims to ensure a feasible concentration¹³13. Cury JA, Dantas EDV, Tenuta LMA, Romão DA, Tabchoury CPM, Nóbrega DF, et al. Concentração de fluoreto nos dentifrícios a base de MFP/CaCO3 mais vendidos no Brasil, ao final dos seus prazos de validade. Rev Assoc Paul Cir Dent. 2015;69(3):248-51. even for small Brazilian toothpaste manufacturers, so as not to sideline them from the competition with multinational companies, considering that they are the ones that win the bids made by the Brazilian Public Health System¹¹11. Cury JA, Miranda LFB, Caldarelli PG, Tabchoury CPM. Dentifrícios fluoretados e o SUS-Brasil: o que precisa ser mudado? Tempus Actas Saude Coletiva. 2020;14(1):9-27. https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.2631
https://doi.org/10.18569/tempus.v14i1.26... .

CONCLUSION

Considering the serious problems of quantity and quality of fluoride in toothpaste brands distributed by the SUS in Manaus, the main conclusion of this article is that a revision of ANVISA RDC No. 530 and world regulations would ensure that not only Brazilians, but also citizens of other developing countries, no longer run the risk of using fluoride toothpaste that is potentially ineffective in controlling dental caries.

Acknowledgements

To technician at the Laboratory of Oral Biochemistry at FOP-Unicamp, Mr. José Alfredo Silva, for his technical support.

REFERENCES

Publication Dates

History